The triumph of the book: Why the printed book is back
BY Richard Glover
29th Nov 2023 Life
3 min read
![The triumph of the book: Why the printed book is back](https://rd-prod.twic.pics/2023-11-28/pyhEYH5Kj5YLGDrM42gZRX8CrjEyYyySiDZOnBSh.jpg?twic=v1/resize=1280/quality=73/focus=auto)
In the debate about which is better, the printed book or the digital device, it seems that the hard-copy book is harder to knock out than originally thought. Here's why
The printed book is back. Recent
studies have shown that students retain more information when they read a
hard-copy book compared to reading on a digital device.
One school near where I live in
Australia responded to these findings by ditching its e-readers. The students
found, according to a teacher, that “the ease of navigation” was superior when
using a traditional book.
Navigational devices on our hands
I love the way we now judge
printed books using the language of the digital world. E-books may come with a
“suite of navigational tools,” but it turns out that the best navigational
devices are your forefinger and thumb.
You can use them to flip the pages
forward and backward. To think, all this time, those devices have just been
just sitting there, dangling at the ends of your arms.
Search tools and bookmarks
Fans of digital books may point
out that e-readers have a handy “search” tool. Old-fashioned books also have a
search function, in which you turn back to the opening chapter to remind
yourself of the hero’s surname.
"Old-fashioned books even have a 'bookmark system', which uses a simple device called a bookmark"
They even have a “bookmark system,” which uses
a device called a “bookmark.”
Progress by the spine
Can a traditional book offer all
the features of an e-book? Alas, no. It lacks a “progress bar” indicating what
percentage of the book has been read. Luckily, a “hack” is available: Turn your
book so that it can be viewed from the side or top.
It will naturally form two
halves joined in the middle (“the spine”). If the left-hand chunk is thicker
than the right-hand one, you are more than halfway through.
Pencil system
Fans of the e-book point out that
digital text is easy to annotate. Some devices even feature a little image of a
pencil to guide the reader through the process. Traditional-book users have a
similar system called a “pencil.” With it, favoured passages can be underlined
and, if it’s a history book, pretentious comments can be written in the margin,
such as “Not so, according to The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.”
"Annotated books can be left around to convince family members of your intellectual perspicacity"
Thus annotated, such books can be
left around for others to peruse, convincing family members, or prospective
lovers, of your intellectual perspicacity.
A book workout
Admittedly, e-books are lighter
than paper volumes, but one must question whether this is really an advantage.
In secondary school my physique was transformed by the daily need to carry
science textbooks.
For me and my fellow students, placing these weighty tomes
in our backpacks would draw our shoulders back and our chests forward in a way
that turned the school into the equivalent of a military parade ground.
Sound baffle and store of knowledge
The printed book, of course, has
other advantages. A full bookshelf is at once a sound baffle and a store of
knowledge. And any properly thumbed book will always fall open at the sexiest
scene.
"Any properly thumbed book will always fall open at the sexiest scene"
Tidying guru Marie Kondo has said
that she keeps about 30 books at any one time. Those who follow Kondo’s example
may have a less cluttered home, but a large, well-stocked bookshelf is more
meaningful. It’s a map of your life as a reader: the passions that passed and
those that endured. There are books that introduced you to other books, like
friends at a party, and books that nursed you through difficult times.
The smell of possibility
Also, the smell of old books in a
second-hand bookshop is instantly evocative. Yes, it’s a mix of mould and old
paper, but to me it represents possibility. Spend an hour browsing, and you’ll
be sure to stumble across an out-of-print book you thought you’d never find.
Educational fads come and go, so
maybe the shift back to traditional books won’t last. But for the moment, I
find myself standing at attention, flexing my textbook-built shoulders and
saluting their glorious return.
Banner credit: Sam Island
Keep up with the top stories from Reader's Digest by subscribing to our weekly newsletter
Keep up with the top stories from Reader's Digest by subscribing to our weekly newsletter